By TERRY LYONS, Editor of Digital Sports Desk
BOSTON – From the start of the 2025 Major League Baseball season on March 27 until last week (June 6-8) in the Bronx, it took the MLB schedule-makers two months-plus to pit the New York Yankees against their longtime and bitter rivals in the Boston Red Sox. The Sox got the best of that series, dropping the opener but winning the final two games by outscoring the Yankees by a touchdown, 21-14. This weekend, Father’s Day Weekend, they’re doing it again.
Boston defeated New York, 2-1, in 10 innings. The victory came on a Carlos Narvaez knock off the famed Green Monster, scoring the elusive MLB phantom runner (David Hamilton) in an exciting, yet low-scoring game.
On a gorgeous (65-degree, 5 mph wind), not a cloud in the sky night at Fenway Park, the Red Sox opened the series with ace Garrett Crochet on the mound. Crochet, the No. 5 MLB leader in innings pitched, pitched a strong first four frames, allowing only one hit and a walk. He struck Yankees slugger and American League triple crown threat Aaron Judge out twice.
The game, as a whole, produced only four hits over the first four innings, with Yankees SS Anthony Volpe collecting the only hit off Crochet.
The Red Sox squeezed out a lone run in the second inning when SS Trevor Story singled to center field, then stole second base. Boston centerfielder Ceddanne Rafaela singled off New York starter Ryan Yarbrough. When Yarbrough walked rookie second baseman Kristian Campbell in the Red Sox half of the fifth inning, then allowed a base hit to Boston left fielder Rob Refsnyder, New York manager Aaron Boone lifting his left-handed starter and replaced him with right-handed reliever Jonathan Loaisiga who proceeded to strike out both Sox slugger Rafael Devers and No. 3 hitter in first baseman Romy Gonzalez.
Yarbrough threw 4.2 innings, allowing four hits and one earned run. He walked three and struck out three Boston batters while throwing 78 pitches (45 for strikes).
Meanwhile, Crochet steamed-rolled through the Yankees batting order through eight innings, allowing only another hit to Volpe who was doubled-up when NYY left fielder Jasson Dominguez hit a hot grounder to Campbell who flipped to SS Trevor Story for a timely double play in the seventh, then retired the side in order in the eighth.
After loading the bases in the bottom of the eighth Yankees reliever Fernando Cruz worked Story into a long fly ball out to left field, sending the game into the ninth.
With his closer warmed up, Boston manager Alex Coro decided to leave Crochet in the game to attempt a complete game shut-out. Crochet retired No. 2 hitter Ben Rice, then faced Judge.
Crochet fired pitches of 98, 99 and 100 mph and forced a 3-2 count against the Yankees slugger, only to throw a 3-2 fastball that Judge clobbered, clear over the Green Monster in left field. The 98 mph pitch landed some 443 feet away to tie the game, 1-1. It was Judge’s 26th homer of the season and it tied him for the Major League lead for HRs with Seattle catcher Cal Raleigh.
Arnoldis Chapman came in to relieve Crochet who threw a career high 8.1 innings, allowing four hits, one earned run – the homer – while walking one batter and striking out seven. Crochet threw 107 pitches, with 72 for strikes.
The game went into extra innings and Volpe became the phantom runner at second base to start the inning. Volpe attempted to steal third base but was thrown out by Boston catcher Carlos Narvaez (with the play requiring a look at instant replay). After another controversial replay call (on an instant replay ruled a foul ball), the Red Sox retired NY second baseman DJ LeMahieu to send the game to the bottom of the 10th.
Pinch-hitter David Hamilton was placed on second base and Jarren Duran moved him to third on a ground ball to LeMahieu. Play slowed to a crawl, as the Yankees held a team meeting on the mound to discuss strategy with relieve Tim Hill on the hill.
Boston slugger Rafael Devers was intentionally walked to create a force play option and potential double play, and Mayer stepped up to the plate with an opportunity to win the game with a deep fly ball. Mayer struck out.
That sent former Yankee catcher Narvaez to the plate with two out and runners at first and third. Devers strolled to second base on a defensive indifference play and Hill focused on Narvaez.
The catcher stroked a a 2-1 four-seam fastball and it bounced off the Green Monster in left-center field to score Hamilton and secure a 2-1 walk-off victory.
The winning pitcher was Garrett Whitlock (5-0) and the loser was Tim Hill (3-2). The game was played in front of a sell-out crowd of 36,622 fans.